"Brain death"
A lie destined to die


1.    Wertheimer P, Jouvet M, Descotes J. A propos du diagnostic de la mort du systeme nerveux Bans Ic comas avee arrel respiratoire tralt6s par la respiration artificielle. Presse Med; 67:87-8, 1959.

2.    Mollaret P, Goulon M. Le coma depasse (memoire preliminaire). Rev Neurol (Paris); 101:3-15, 1959.

3.     Byrne, PA,' O'Reilly, S., and Quay PM: "Brain Death-an Opposing Viewpoint", JAMA, 242; 1985-1990, 1979.

4.     Evers, JC., and Byrne, PA., "Brain Death-Still A Controversy" The  

         Pharos of Alpha Omega Alpha 53/4. 10-12, 1990.

5.      Pallis, C., and Harley, D.H.: "ABC' of  brainstem death". BMJ Publishing group. London WCIH pp. 1-85, 1996.

6.  Younger, S., and Bartlet E: Human death and high technology: The failure of the whole brain formulation. Ann Inter Med, 99:252-258, 1983.

7. Pallis, C: Brain stem death. The evolution of a concept. Paper presented at the Royal Society of Medicine Meeting Dec. 11,1983

8.  Machado, C: Program of the 2nd international symposium on brain death (Havana, Cuba) Feb 27-Marro 1, 1996. (Abstracts of the meetings). Network for the Definition of Death/Brain Death and end-of-Life Ethics Links.

9.      Smith AJK, Walker AE: Cerebral blood flow and brain metabolism as indicators of cerebral death: A review. John Hopkins Med. J; 133:107-19, 1973.

10.  Jennett B, Gleave J, Wilson P: Brain deaths in three neurosurgical units. BMJ, 282:533-9, 1981.

11.Jorgensen EO: Spinal man after brain death. Acta neurochir (Wien):            

      28:259-73, 1973

12.Lindgren S, Petersen I, Zwetnow N: Prediction of' death in serious    

      brain damage. Acta Chir Scand, 134:406-16, 1968:


13.David R, Field MD, Elena A, Gates Nil) and Robert  K: Maternal  

      brain death during  pregnancy JAMA, 260, 6:816-22 1988.

14.Parisi JE, Kim RC, Collins GH, Hillfinger  MF: Brain death with   

     prolonged somatic survival. N Engl .1 Mcd-, 306:14-16, 1982.


15.Aquino TM, &, Samuels MA: Com and  other alterations in Consciousness.  

    Manual of' Neurologic  therapeuties. Lippincot  Williams and Wilkins :

       p.3-18, 1999

16.  Plum F and Posner .JB: The diagnosis of' stupor and coma.   Philadelphia: LA Davis company, p 2 1-216, 1980.

17.Kinney HC and Samuels MA: Neuropathology of the persistent vegetative             state: A review. J Neuropathology and Experimental Neurology 53:548-558, 1994.

18.The Multi-Society Task Force on PVS: Medical aspects of-' the persistent   

    vegetative state. N Engl. Med J 330:1499-1508, 1994.

19.Plum P: Coma and related global disturbances of the human conscious state.  

   In Peter A (ed) Cerebral Cortex, Vol. 9. New York: Plenum Publishing  Corporation:  359-425, 1991.

20. Villablanca, J and Salinas-Ceballos, ME: Sleep wakefulness, EEG and   

      behavioral  studies of' chronic cats without the thalamus. The   

      athalamic'cat. Arch. Ital Biol.    110:383-411,1972.


21.Mountcastle VB: An organization principle for cerebral function: The unit  

    module  and the distributed  System  in: Edelman GM and Mountcastle VB  

    (eds) Mindful    Brain. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press: 7-50, 1978

22.    Goldman-, Rakie PS: Topography of cognition: Parallel distributed networks in primate association cortex. .Ann Rev. Neurosci. 11:137-1_56, 1988.

23.   Shewmon DA: "Brain Death".A valid theme with invalid variations, blurred by semantic ambiguity. In: Angstwurm H and De Paula C (ed.) Workin Group on the determination of brain death and its relationship to death: Vatican city:Pontificia Academia scientiarum: - pp: 23-51, 1992.

24.   Hassler, R, Dalle Ore G,and Bricolo, OA: Behavioral and EEG arousal induced by stimulation of unspecific projection  systems in a patient with post-traumatic apallic Syndrome. clectroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol; 27:306-10,1969.

25.   Gail, AVN:'A matter of life and death.( Rcv. article) Anesthesiology, Vol. 91, No. 1:275-87, 1999.

26.    Brock M, fieschi C. lngvar DH: Cerebral blood flow. Berlin: springer- verlag, P. 69 -81, 1969

27.    Ashwal S, Schneider S.: Failure of electroeneephalography to

       diagnose In brain death in comatose children. Ann NCLII'01-, 6:512-7,1979.

28.   Bricolo A, Dalle Ore G. Da Pian R, l3cmiti A. TUI-ClIa G. In: Fusek, A, Kunc, N,eds. Present limits of neurosurgery. Prague: Avicenum,     p. 73-176, 1972.

29.   Albertini A,Schonfeld S, Hiatt M, Hegyi T.: Digital substraction angiography a new approach to brain death determination in the newborn. Pediatr  Radiol; 23:195-7, 1993.

30.   Schlake HP, Bottger IG, Grotemeyer  KH  Husstedt IW, Brandau W, Schober  O. Intensive Care Medicine, 18:76-81, 1992.

31.   Wilson K, Gordon L, Selby J Sr. The diagnosis of brain death with Tc-99m HMPAO. Clin  Nucl Med: 18:428-34. 1993.

32.     Wieler H, Marohl K, Kaiser KP, Klawki P. Frossler H.: Tc-99m HMPAO cerebral scintigraphy. A reliable noninvasive method for determination of brain death. Clin NUCI Med;


33.  De la Riva A, Gonzalez FM, Llamas- Elvira JM. Latre JM, Jinenez-Heffernan A, Vidal E.: Diagnosis of brain death: Superiority of perfusion studies with     Tc-99pl HMPAO over conventional radionuclide cerebral angiography. Br J Radio : 65:289-94. 1992

34.     Petty GW, Mohr JP, Pedley TA, Tatcniichi TK. Lennihan L, Duterte DI: The role of transcranial Doppler in confirming brain death. Neurology; 40:300-3, 1990.

35.   Davalos A, Rodriguez-Rago A, Mate G, Molins A. Genic D, Gonzalez JL.: Value of, (lie transcranial Doppler examination in the diagnosis of brain death. Med Clin, 100:249-52, 1993.

36.   Jones KM, Barnes PD.: MR diagnosis  of brain death. American Journal of  neuroradiology; 13:65-6, 1992.

37.   Firsching R, Reinhold A F, Williclins S, Buchholz F.: Brain death:

Practicability of evoked potentials. Neurosurg  Rev; 15:249-54, 1992.

38. Guerit M.: Evoked potentials: A safe brain-death confirmatory tool. Eur J Med; 1:233-43, 1992

39.   Erbengi A. Erbengi G. Cataltepe O. Topeu M. Erbas B. Aras T.: Brain death: Determination with brainstem evoked potentials and radionuclide isotope studies. Acta  Neurochr- (Wien); 112:118-25, 1991.

40.   Palma V, Guadagnino M.: Evoked potentials in brain death. A critical review. Acta Neurologica:, 14:363-68. 1992.

41.. Schmitt B, Simma B, Burger R, Dumermuth G: Resuscitation after severe   

       hypoxia in a young child : temporary isoelectric EEG and loss of brainstem  

        auditory evoked   potentials components. Intensive care medicine     19: 420-2,1993

42. Imberi R, Filisetti P, Preseglio I. Mapelli  A. Spriano P.: Confirmation   

      of  brain death utilizing thyrotropin – releasing  hormone stimulation test.

       Neurosurgery    :27:167. 1990

43.Buchner 11, Schuchardt V.: Reliability  of electroeneephalogram in the  diagnosis of' 

     brain death. eur. Neurol : 30:138-41, 1990.

44.Bernat  JL: : Brain death occurs, only with destruction of the cerebral hemispheres and   

        brainstem Arch Ncurpol 49:569-70, 1992.

45.Barber N.: The Nasty side of organ transplanting. ( the cannibalisticnature of transplant  

      medicine 3 nd edition 2007 . Adelide south Australia, Australia standardoil @ hotmail . com,  

         gumflat 88 @ hotmail.com

46. Darby JM, Yonas H. Gur D. . Latchaw RI_: "Xenon-enchanted computed  

      tomography in brain death". Arch. Neurol, 44(5)P:551-4, 1987.

47.Jennett 13: "Brain death' British J Of Anesthesia vol. 53, No. 11, I 11 1-19, 198 1.


48.Starr A: "Average evoked brain potentials mid brain death" Proceedings of



   the 1st international symposium on brain death. in Havana

    p:11-12, 1992

49. Biniek R, Ferbert A. Buchner H, bruckmann H: "Loss of brainstem       acoustic evoked potentials wilh spontaneous breathing in a patient With  supratentorial lesion: EUR Neurol  3O (1) P38-41, 1990.

50.BuchnerH. schuchrdt V. : Reliability of electroeneephalogram in diagnosis of brain   

     death. Eur. Ncurol. 30: 138-41, 1990.

51.Carbonell .1, Carrascosa G. Diersen S: some  electrophysiological observations in case of deep Coma secondary to cardiac arrest. Electroeneephalogr. Clin Neurophysiol . 15:520-5, 1963.

52.. Hill DJ: The Lazarus Phenomenon Re- visited.H  Anesthesiology

  V79  No 6, p. 1438, 1993.

53.Gelb AW. Robertson KM: "Anaesthetic management of the brain dead z:I

for organ donation". Can-1. Anacsth. 37:7. p. 806-12, 1990.

54.Gramm HJ. Zimmermann H• Meinhold R.: I Hemodynamic responses to noxious stimuli in brain dead organ donors. Inter. Care Med 18:493-495, 1992.

55.Bernard LO-, "Determination of death, in: Resolving ethical dilemmas"

      2nd ed. Lippincott Williams and wilkins. Philadelphia, p. 177-80,2000

56.Yokota HB, Nakazawa S, Shimurn T, Kimura A. Yamamoto Y, Ot'Suka T: "Hypothalamic and pituitary Function in brain death". Neurol Med chir.(Tokyo) Dec31(13) p.881-6.1991

57.Gando, S, Kitmai K. Tsujinagalt Matsubara I, Ando M, Tcdo I: "Non-clostridial gas-producing brain abscess in  a brain dead patient. Report of      a case". No-to-shinkei . mar 40(3) p. 247-52, 1988.

58.Coad NR, Byrne A.I: "Guillain- Barre syndrome  mimicking brain stem death". Anaesthesia. J un. -45(6). P 456-7. 1990

59.Hassan T, Mumford C: "Guillain-Barre syndrome mistaken for brain stem death". Postorad-Med. .J. Mar. 67(785), p. 280-1, 1991.

60.Lock M: When bodies outlive persons. Twice dead, organ transplants and the reinvention  of death. 1st ed. University of California Press. Berkeley & L.A. pp. 235-260. 2002.

61- Dr. David wainwright Evans, Former cardiologist at papworth hospital, cambridgeshire, united kingdom . personal  correspondence to the author. ( Quoted from Ref. no. 45 P:22)

62- Watanabe Yoshio” why do I stand against the movement  for cardiac transplantation in Japan” from the Cardiovascular institute, fujita  health university  school of medicine Toyoale, Japan July 21, 1994

Dr Watanabe recommends the following for further reference;

Dowie, M. we have  a donor. A bold new world of organ transplanting, Japanese  translation by M. Hirasawa, Heibon – sha, Tokyo 1990

Kimbrel, S. the human body shop the engineering and marketing of life, Japanese translation by S. Fukuoka Tokyo. Kagaku Dojin- sha 1995

63..Jennett B, Hessett C: Brain death  in Britain as reflected in renal donors.

BMJ: 283:359-62, 1981.

64. Lotfy, SH: Brain death does  not  imply  death. (Editorial). The Egypt .j `Surg. Vol. 11, No. 3, p. 5, 1992.